Tom’s Crossing - Will Webster Reviews

Tom’s Crossing is a modern epic that genuinely rivals titles like Moby Dick, the Odyssey or the Iliad.

I began it blind. I bought it because it was Danielewski and it was in the bookshop. I’d only ever read one of his other novels, which was House of Leaves. That was enough of an endorsement for an instant purchase.

For a while, I was confused: I hadn’t known what to expect, but I wasn’t expecting a story about two boys who became friends because they loved horses. I kept reading, despite the slow pace, despite the fact that I don’t care for westerns, and despite the fact that I could only read the multi-hour chapters in short snippets. Then about 120 pages in the story turned on its head. The villain who had been mostly odious and vaguely threatening, became simultaneously believably human, and unbelievably monstrous. Someone self-interested, devious, and superbly capable. The story became compelling then, and it soon morphed until it was completely unrecognisable as that unassuming and inconspicuous tale laid out in the first chapter.

I did a few double takes on pages once my brain caught up to what I had just read. I started googling the references to Dante’s Divine Comedy. I dusted the cobwebs from my memory of biblical stories about prodigal sons returning, which this story mixes in with Jacob and Esau’s story of inheritance, except here it went to the son who behaved like Cain instead of Abel. I looked up Chronos eating his children (that particular thread I didn’t find anyone else talking about). I flipped backwards through pages for the spelling mistakes that I now realised were double entendres (looking at you, liminite (liminal/laminite)). I began hunting down wordplay, callbacks to other mythological stories, and hidden meanings behind what was in plain sight. And that carried on for hundreds of pages, while I became more invested in the story of two children, leading some horses up the mountains.

Their situation was grim, as though Frodo and Sam spent the entire length of their journey on the jagged plains of Mordor, hungry, exposed, and hunted. The protagonists are hopelessly stripped of power and information, while the antagonists have access to information, and the structures of power in society at their disposal. That imbalance reminded me at times of Stephen King, and at other times the poetry reminded me of Cormac McCarthy. Mostly though, the book reminded me of nothing I’d ever read.

See this is a story that changes based on the angle you view it from. It is a mythic tale of a person through whom moves ancient gods on the one side. It is a classic hero’s journey from the other side. Other times it’s mostly a sad story about broken families. On one page it revels in its refusal to being pinned down as any one thing, and in others it argues, vehemently, with itself about what it is. It is both an example and examination of, the art of storytelling, the evolution of traditions that make the old tales relevant to our milieu. It argues that myths cannot capture truly heroic events, because the foregone conclusion of their ending minimises the journeys that inspired them. In its own words: “We forget the endurance required, the guts. We satisfy ourselves with the results, and even worse, the representation of results, makin the consideration of what did happen no longer necessary.” and yet “the journey don’t count if we don’t finish it.”

It examines in great detail that the story can only exist because of the ones that came before, and yet: “The prototypes of the past are pedagogical on a good day and a prison on a bad day. Traditions built out of repetitions prove nothin except their own evolvin memory. In the end, (…) the question was whether we needed construction in the first place.” Tom’s Crossing rejects its influences, and then embraces them. It struggles with and against itself. It argues over what it itself means, like a person tearing their hair out in an existential crisis. This is a book populated with Latin and Greek, myth and history, personal experience, and academic inquiry.

Most of all, Tom’s Crossing is clearly written by someone who loves stories, loves them down to their DNA - the tropes, arcs, meanings, metaphors, signs, and signifiers that make up the anatomy of the enduring tales. This book could only have been written by someone who knows their literature backwards and forwards, who struggles with them in the way you could only struggle with an object of abject affection. Someone who must have become exhausted by literature, and yet cannot help but dedicate their life to it.

I followed his arguments with my own. He encapsulates the internal voices that plague writers, and manages to write an excellent book while doing so. This book reminded me why I love stories, and why I love writing. I don’t have too much more to say about it, but I’ll leave you with this bit, which feels like the author telling us a bit about his process:

“I’ve decided to write it all down (…) I’ll make it all up except this part (…) I don’t need to make this part up. I just need to remember it. And I’ve got a good memory. I’ll also take them things I love, the people, the good moments, and I’ll mix them up so none of it will really be what it was, but it’ll still carry that, I don’t know, that glow that makes life so special. You know, by the end your heart’ll be broken but healed too, if that makes sense. Names too, I’ll switch them around, so who they really was will haunt who they ain’t really. Writers can do that: mix up made-up stuff with the mixed-up real stuff, so it’s familiar but it also ain’t too familiar. Like how our head makes sense of stuff by makin up what’s missin(...) She’d write a place where dreams find their logical extension and know themselves inadequate. It’ll be humble and lardy-dardy at the same time. And I’ll use little words but big words too. And I’ll use lots of them. Our daddy used to tell us just usin a few words or worst of all one word don’t give you no better handle on things. Like, do you really think the word apple is an apple? That one word, apple, don’t come close to what the apples in the world really are. And horse? Can you imagine? I’ll use every word I can think of, and if I can’t think of one, then I’ll make one up. (…) sayin how it weren’t even important to get everything right but just to see that what was right rhymed with what you had in mind was right.”

Oh, and here are a few snippets that I thought went hard, as the kids say:

  • “(The bible is) the one book she lives by but will never read, parts of, sure, but not straight through.”

  • “I’d love to not have three jobs. I do it for (spoiler). And ain’t that the pickle, when you gotta leave the one you love to love the one you love?”

  • “When I was in my twenties, it all seemed within reach, (…) but I’m old enuf now to see it’s always been out of reach (…) I guess I’ve lived long enuf to see the life I wanted give way to the life I got.”

  • “Great Power in its purest form is a great power because it will not deliver mercy.”

  • “Lucky are them, most will say, whose futures align with the promise of their inheritances.”

  • “To debase yourself ain’t the same thing as to erase yourself.”

  • “No matter what whimsy or the personal need to express overtook the subject matter here, the subject matter still refused to budge, rooted in a very specific moment in history that now seemed especially ghostly.”

  • “Myth can make reality more intelligible.”

  • “The gods of Mount Olympus are long gone. So it Mount Olympus (..) the one memory which we only faintly know, that includes our collective history, and is that memory that metes out its contents upon the scales of universal balance.”

  • “I suspect saints are saints because they know the full price and still pay it.”

  • “What’s so dangerous about nostalgia is that it makes the paramount present suddenly negotiable.”

  • “A song doesn’t need justice, just someone to sing it.”

  • “What if by doubt we mean we are curious instead? What if by hopelessness we mean we find wonderment?”

  • “I’m not sure that there are ghosts or even the dead. There’s just those poor myths that’ve been blindin us from ourselves for ages: who we are, where we are, what’s right there in front of us.

  • “If there are regrets, it’s that we didn’t hurl ourselves more into the dark while we still thought our heart a lamp.”

  • “What is written is Word, but what is repeated is World.”

  • “Church leads to the sort of family you’d want to see reassembled in any afterlife. And as wholesome as that sounds, it has a way of sayin what kind of family’s right, and in doin that, it refuses other kinds of livin, Good livin. From there it’s just a matter of steps before this kind of preachin is just another means to acquirin power and writin laws retainin that power. Heedless too that them supposedly Good Families have by their lineage gone on to produce factions, sectarian violence, even armies set against one another, set against anythin Good (…) a church that seeks out the enforcement of its beliefs is a faithless settlement.”

  • “When you’ve still found the courage to turn from modern claims on your attention to listen there in your solitude to the great Breath that holds us all in its Grace, mullin over the sheer impossibility as well as inevitability of all that was about to transpire, those terrible odds, with the even more terrifyin consequences such odds decreed; what will make any heart glad for the bedsheets another night grants, what a new day of old routines helps deny; that which renders contemptible if not outright cowardly even the greatest acts of darin, the measure of which makes any man who thinks he’s such a man know hisself as far lesser; what makes any woman gladder for knowin the world is made of lesser men; because if what is to come were the standard by which we are all measured, well then, as you likely also know, not even a few would find themselves still standin let alone with strength enuf to share the tale.”

Next
Next